Skip to Content

How to make box brownies more fudgy (7 best tips)

Sharing is caring!

We've all been there. You're craving something sweet, and then you remember that trusty box of brownie mix sitting in your pantry. But here's the thing, just because it's a box mix doesn't mean it can't taste like decadent, homemade brownies. There are a few simple tweaks you can apply to transform those ordinary box brownies into the fudgiest, most scrumptious treats! Our 7 tips will help answer your question how to make box brownies more fudgy.

Brownies on a plate and title How to make box brownies more fudgy

Making the perfect brownie (how to make box brownies more fudgy)

Alright, so you want to know how to make box brownies more fudgy? You're in for a treat. These hacks aren't just about adding an ingredient or two; it's about understanding the science and art behind those delightful squares of chocolate bliss. Let's delve deeper into the brownie universe and elevate that box mix to a level that'll have your friends and family begging for your 'secret' recipe:

  • Swap Vegetable Oil with Melted Butter: It's not just about the richness that melted butter provides, but also the depth of flavor. Vegetable oil is primarily fat without any flavor, whereas butter gives you both fat and that wonderful, creamy taste we associate with the best brownies. Using unsalted butter allows you to control the saltiness, highlighting the cocoa powder's depth in the mix. Pro tip? Brown that butter for an even deeper, nuttier undertone. It'll be our little secret.
    TWO WEEK FREE Trial to VidAngel

    ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ "VidAngel is exactly what I needed! Filtering out the stuff I don't want to see makes family movie night so much better."

    With VidAngel, you get:

    ✅ Control over your viewing: Filter out language, nudity, violence, and more!

    ✅ Family-friendly entertainment: Enjoy your favorite movies and shows worry-free.

    ✅ Peace of mind: Create a viewing experience that aligns with your values.

    ✅ Watch what you want: VidAngel works with popular streaming services.

    ✅ Affordable for everyone: Plans start at just $9.99/month.

    ✅ Try it FREE for TWO WEEKS! What have you got to lose?

    Join today! What are you waiting for?

    We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
  • The Power of an Extra Egg: While the back of the box usually suggests 2 large eggs, adding an extra one can dramatically alter the texture. The protein in the egg yolks gives the brownies structure, while the fat ensures they're moist. By adding an extra whole egg, you're ensuring the brownie is richer and has that melt-in-your-mouth fudgy texture.
  • Rethink That Water: The idea is simple; reducing the water content will give a denser result. But, if you're feeling a tad adventurous, why not swap that water for brewed coffee or instant espresso? It won’t make your brownies taste like coffee but will intensify the chocolate flavor, adding layers of depth to your boxed mix.
  • Mix But Keep It Gentle: Brownie batter is delicate. You want to mix enough to combine your dry ingredients with the wet, but the moment you overdo it, you're activating the gluten in the mix. This leads to cakey, not fudgy brownies. So, a gentle hand ensures a fudgy outcome.
  • Pan Size Matters: Opting for a smaller, square pan doesn't just mean thicker brownies. It also affects how they cook. In a smaller pan, the heat distributes differently, ensuring the edges are crispy, while the center remains fudgy and dense. Make sure to line it with parchment paper or aluminum foil for effortless removal.
  • The Underbaking Philosophy: Overbaked brownies lose their fudginess. Period. Always check a tad earlier than the box suggests. Look for a few moist crumbs on the toothpick, which are the indicators of a perfectly fudgy brownie waiting to be devoured.
  • Cooling Is Key: Yes, the aroma is intoxicating, and yes, it’s hard to wait. But brownies continue to cook slightly from the residual heat even after being pulled out from the oven. Letting them cool ensures the middle settles into that dense, fudgy texture you've worked to achieve.
  • Unleash Your Mix-In Creativity: Think of your box mix as a canvas. Chocolate chips, melted chocolate, white chocolate chunks, or even a drizzle of caramel sauce can take your brownies from delicious to 'Oh my, what sorcery is this?' Add-ins aren't just about taste; they can significantly alter texture, making every bite a surprise.
Wilton Performance Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan, 8-Inch, 8, Silver

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/11/2024 07:08 am GMT

7 best tips How to make box brownies more fudgy

To make box brownies more fudgy, use extra fat sources such as melted butter in place of oil and add an additional egg. Reduce the amount of water and avoid overmixing the batter. For best results, slightly underbake and allow them to cool in the pan to achieve a dense, fudgy texture.

Print up this free best tips for how to make box brownies more fudgy so you always have it on hand.

recipe card style free printable for fudgy brownie tips.

Key Takeaways for Next-Level Brownies

Navigating the world of boxed brownies can sometimes feel like you're preparing a recipe card for the first time. But worry not, brownie lover! Here are your essentials, your brownie mix hacks if you will, to transform that boxed brownie mix into decadent brownies that taste homemade:

  • Butter Over Vegetable Oil: Swap out that vegetable oil for melted butter, preferably at room temperature. This isn't just a brownie hack; it's a game-changer. Melted butter gifts your brownies with that richer flavor that makes chocolate lovers swoon.
  • Eggs - The Fudgy Magic Wand: A simple equation to remember - extra eggs equal denser, chewier brownies. This isn't just about moisture; it's about the texture and structure eggs lend to the mix.
  • Hydration Matters: The easy way to fudgier brownies? Use less water. This little trick can make a big difference in your brownie mix taste.
  • The Delicate Art of Mixing: If you’re looking for that perfect brownie with a crinkly top and fudgy center, avoid overmixing. Overdoing it leads to a cake-like texture. And while there's nothing wrong with cake, it's not the fudgy delight we're aiming for here.
  • Pan Decisions: Your choice in a baking dish is crucial. A square baking pan is your best bet to ensure thicker brownies, which further enhances their fudgy texture.
  • The Underbake Philosophy: Achieving the perfect brownie often means baking at a slightly lower temperature and always being mindful of your baking time. Underbaking just a smidge ensures that melt-in-your-mouth fudgy texture.
  • Patience in Cooling: After you’ve taken them out of the oven, resist the temptation! Allowing your brownies to cool in the prepared pan is essential. They continue setting, ensuring every bite is just right.
  • Unleash Your Creative Side: Mix-ins are the secret ingredients that can make your brownies go from delicious to 'Where have these been all my life?' Think candy bars, cream cheese swirls, or even marshmallow fluff. As a personal favorite brownie mix hack: sprinkle some crushed peppermint patties for a refreshing twist!

Remember, every box of brownie mix holds the potential for a masterpiece. It's not just about following the instructions to the letter but about understanding how each ingredient and step contributes to the final product. The best part? Once you master these tips, you can confidently experiment, tweak, and make every batch of box brownie mix uniquely yours. So, the next time someone asks about your "secret ingredients," just wink and say it's all in the technique. 

How to make box brownies more fudgy FAQ:

1. What makes a brownie more fudgy?

The fudgier texture in brownies predominantly comes from fat, like butter, eggs, and of course, chocolate. By tweaking these components, especially by introducing extra ingredients with fat or trimming down the amount of purpose flour, you're on your way to achieving that next level fudginess in your brownies. This is one of those brownie hacks that can take your brownie box mix from average to exceptional!

2. What does adding an extra egg to brownie mix do?

Eggs are the unsung heroes of brownie mixes. They contribute both moisture and fat. Tossing in an extra egg amplifies the density of the brownie, steering it closer to that chewier brownie texture we all adore. It's an easy recipe tweak with a big payoff.

3. How do you jazz up a box of brownies?

Jazzing up your boxed mixes is a delightful journey! Think about mix-ins: dark chocolate chunks, white chocolate chips, or even the surprise of peanut butter chips. Want a delightful crunch? How about sprinkling some potato chips on top for a salty-sweet combo. If you're in the mood for a chilly treat, adding a dollop of ice cream can take it a long way. And never underestimate the power of a sprinkle of sea salt on the top; it's a game-changer for chocolate flavor elevation.

Betty Crocker Delights Supreme Chocolate Chunk Brownie Mix, 18 oz.
$2.42 ($0.13 / Ounce)

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/11/2024 06:53 am GMT

4. How do you doctor up Betty Crocker brownie mix?

Whether you're a fan of Betty Crocker or any other brand, the principle remains consistent. Consider adding espresso powder or even a dash of whole milk for a richer and deeper chocolate flavor. Melted chocolate or even a splash of heavy cream can increase the richness. And here's a not-so-secret tip: a dash of vanilla extract often makes all the difference in boxed brownies. It's all about using those extra ingredients wisely.

Parchment Paper Baking Sheets

Buy Now
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/11/2024 07:13 am GMT

5. Is it a good idea to use parchment paper or aluminum foil?

Oh, absolutely! Think of parchment paper or foil as your trusty sidekicks. Not only do they ensure your delicious brownies don't end up sticking to the pan, but they also pave the way for even cooking. Another added advantage is when it's time to store any leftover brownies; using an airtight container ensures they stay moist and fresh. And if you're looking for the best way to serve and store, don't forget to let them cool to room temperature first!


There you have it! With these simple tweaks, your box mix brownies can rival any homemade brownie recipes. So the next time you reach for that box in your pantry, remember these tricks to ensure every bite is filled with dense, fudgy deliciousness. Happy baking, chocolate brownies enthusiasts!

Pin how to make box brownies more fudgy for later

A close-up photograph of freshly baked fudgy brownies, showcasing their rich, moist texture and glossy chocolatey top.

Sharing is caring!