Skip to Content

Vegan mayo vs regular mayo: Homemade mayonnaise

Sharing is caring!

Let's be honest, mayo is that quintessential ingredient that makes sandwiches perfect, dips divine, and salads delectable. But in recent years, with the rise of the plant-based diet, there's a new contender in the condiment aisle: vegan mayo. In this blog post, we'll delve deep into the world of vegan mayo vs regular mayo, comparing everything from taste to texture. And as an extra treat, I'll also share my very own vegan mayo recipe which has saved countless BBQs and picnics!

vegan mayo in a bowl

What Makes Vegan Mayo Vegan?

Vegan mayo is just as its name suggests—a vegan alternative to traditional mayonnaise. The main ingredient in regular mayonnaise is egg yolks, which give it that creamy texture. But vegan mayo replaces animal products, like egg yolks, with plant-based ingredients to achieve that same creamy consistency.

ingredients in bowls
TWO WEEK FREE Trial to VidAngel

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ "VidAngel is exactly what I needed! Filtering out the stuff I don't want to see makes family movie night so much better."

With VidAngel, you get:

✅ Control over your viewing: Filter out language, nudity, violence, and more!

✅ Family-friendly entertainment: Enjoy your favorite movies and shows worry-free.

✅ Peace of mind: Create a viewing experience that aligns with your values.

✅ Watch what you want: VidAngel works with popular streaming services.

✅ Affordable for everyone: Plans start at just $9.99/month.

✅ Try it FREE for TWO WEEKS! What have you got to lose?

Join today! What are you waiting for?

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Key Ingredients Found in Vegan Mayo:

  • Soy milk (though almond milk is also popular!)
  • Avocado oil or other healthier oils like grapeseed oil, olive oil, and sunflower oil
  • Lemon juice or apple cider vinegar for that tangy kick
  • Sometimes, brown rice syrup or cane sugar for a hint of sweetness
  • Common stabilizers include food starch and soy protein

One thing's for sure: whether you're on a vegan diet for animal welfare, have an egg allergy, or just enjoy plant-based foods, there's a vegan mayo for you.

mayo in a white bowl

Vegan Mayonnaise 


  • 1 cup vegetable oil
  • ½ cup soy milk
  • ½ lemon, juiced
  • 1 tbsp red wine vinegar
  • 2 tsp Dijon mustard
  • Pinch of cane sugar
  • Salt, to taste


  • Add the soy milk to a food processor or immersion blender and process for about 1 minute until the milk becomes foamy.
  • Then add the vegetable oil, lemon juice, red wine vinegar, Dijon mustard, sugar and salt to the soy milk in the processor and process for about 2-3 minutes until it becomes thick and creamy.
  • If you feel like the mayonnaise is a little too thin, you can add a little bit more oil to it.
  • You can keep this cool in the fridge for about 1 week.
  • Enjoy!

Comparing Vegan Mayo vs Regular Mayo: A Deeper Dive

When you put a jar of vegan mayo next to its conventional counterpart, you might think they're quite similar just by appearance. But dive a bit deeper, and there's a world of difference, both subtle and pronounced. Let's take a more detailed journey into these differences and similarities:

Texture and Consistency:

Both types aim for that rich, velvety, creamy texture that we all adore in our sandwiches and salads. Traditional mayonnaise achieves this primarily through egg yolks. The lecithin in the yolks acts as an emulsifier, giving mayo its iconic consistency. Vegan mayo, on the other hand, needs to find clever plant-based ways to emulate this. Soy milk, with its natural lecithin, combined with vegetable oil, becomes the hero here, stepping up to deliver a consistency that can sometimes make you question if it’s not the real thing. Another player that sometimes enters the scene is food starch, adding to the creamy consistency.


The taste of regular mayonnaise is well-defined, predominantly by the egg yolks it contains, but also by the monounsaturated fats from the oils used. Vegan mayo, in its quest to mimic this taste, offers a broad palette of flavors. Depending on its primary ingredients, you could detect subtle undertones of coconut oil or the bright tanginess of lemon juice or apple cider vinegar. Some brands or homemade recipes might even use mustard flour or yellow mustard, giving an added layer of depth to the taste.

Nutritional Value:

Without diving into health specifics, it's still essential to note the difference in nutritional components. The fat content in regular mayo arises mainly from egg yolks and whatever oil is used. Vegan mayo, on the other hand, sources its fats from a range of oils, including avocado oil, canola oil, and sometimes even grapeseed oil. This shift in oils can lead to a variation in the types of fatty acids present. For instance, avocado oil is rich in monounsaturated fats, while canola has a balance of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats.


Beyond the plate, our food choices have global implications. Adopting vegan mayo is more than just a dietary preference; for many, it's a conscious choice for the planet. The production of eggs can have various environmental impacts, including greenhouse gas emissions and significant water usage. By switching to vegan mayo, one supports a reduction in these impacts, echoing a commitment to sustainability and animal welfare.


I remember a time when opting for vegan alternatives would often mean a heftier price tag. The niche market and specialized ingredients often drove costs up. However, as demand has surged and plant-based diets have gained traction, economies of scale have started to favor the consumer. With big players like Hampton Creek's 'Just Mayo' and Hellmann’s Vegan Mayo jumping into the fray, vegan mayo is not just accessible in most grocery aisles but also comparably priced to traditional mayo. You'll still find artisanal vegan mayo brands that might be pricier, but the range of choices ensures there's something for every budget.

bowl of mayonnaise

Tips When Opting for Vegan Mayo: Enhancing Your Plant-Based Experience

Embarking on the journey of vegan mayo is an adventure in itself. Whether you're a seasoned vegan or someone dipping their toes into plant-based alternatives, there are a few things you should keep in mind:

1. Brands Matter:

Dive Deep into Brand Landscapes: With the surge in plant-based diets, several brands have emerged, each bringing its unique twist to vegan mayo. Hampton Creek's 'Just Mayo' is renowned for its creamy texture and natural flavor. Best Foods offers a blend that mirrors their non-vegan mayo, making it a favorite for those transitioning to a vegan diet. Hellmann's Vegan Mayo, backed by its long-standing reputation in the condiment world, ensures a quality alternative that doesn't skimp on flavor.

Organize a Taste-Test Party: What's better than trying new foods? Doing it with friends! Hosting a vegan mayo taste test can not only be enlightening but also a whole lot of fun. Grab different brands, whip up some fries or veggie sticks, and let the tasting begin. You might discover your new favorite or appreciate the nuanced differences each brand brings.

2. Check the Ingredients:

It’s not just about being vegan; it’s about what suits your palate and dietary preferences. If you're avoiding certain oils, like coconut oil, due to its distinct flavor, or have an allergy to ingredients like soy, reading the label is crucial. Moreover, some vegan mayos might include additional flavors or natural stabilizers like maize starch, so always ensure they align with your dietary needs.

3. Storage:

While it might be tempting to leave that jar of vegan mayo on your countertop after making a sandwich, don't. Vegan mayo, despite lacking animal products, still contains ingredients that can spoil. Always refrigerate after opening, ensuring its shelf life is maximized. And if you've just whipped up a fresh batch of homemade vegan mayo using our earlier recipe, remember that its freshness is at its peak during the first week. Use a clean utensil every time to avoid contamination.

4. Versatility:

Vegan mayo isn't just a sandwich spread. Its creamy texture and delightful taste make it an excellent addition to a variety of dishes. Try using it as a base for creamy dressings in salads, or mix it with some herbs and spices for a quick dip. Those crispy french fries? They've found their perfect partner in vegan mayo. And let's not forget classics like potato salad, coleslaw, or vegan burgers; with vegan mayo, these dishes not only become plant-friendly but also deliciously rich. Embrace the versatility, and don't be afraid to experiment!


1. Is vegan mayo gluten-free?

Most vegan mayo brands and recipes, including the one I've provided, are gluten-free. However, always check the label to be sure, especially if you have a gluten allergy.

2. How does the use of avocado oil or olive oil change the taste?

These oils provide a richer and sometimes fruitier undertone. Avocado oil offers a buttery flavor, while olive oil can be slightly pungent.

3. Can I use vegan mayo in all recipes calling for regular mayo?

Absolutely! It's a fantastic substitute and works brilliantly in almost all recipes.

4. How long does homemade vegan mayo last in the fridge?

Generally, it can last up to a week. However, it's always best to consume it within a few days for the best flavor.

5. What if I want a lighter version?

Some brands offer light mayo options, and when making your own vegan mayo, you can adjust the oil to achieve fewer calories and a lighter texture.

toast with mayo and tomatoes

Key Takeaways: Dive Deeper into the World of Vegan Mayo

Navigating the vibrant world of vegan mayo vs regular mayo, you'll realize there's more than meets the eye (or the palate). Here are the detailed insights I've gathered for you:

1. A Plant-based Revelation:

Vegan mayo isn't just a random alternative concocted in a lab. It's a well-thought-out, delectable substitute for traditional mayonnaise, especially catering to those embracing a plant-based lifestyle or those navigating the challenges of egg allergies. By eliminating animal products, it also stands as a testament to animal welfare and sustainable eating choices.

2. The Power of Ingredients:

While eggs are the backbone of conventional mayo, vegan mayo finds its strength in an ensemble of plant-based ingredients. Soy milk steps in as a perfect egg substitute, bringing in the required emulsification. Avocado oil, rich in monounsaturated fats, gives it a creamy base, while lemon juice adds that zesty kick ensuring it's not just a bland spread but a taste sensation.

3. Taste the Rainbow:

While traditional mayo has a somewhat consistent flavor profile, vegan mayo offers a palette of flavors. The primary ingredients used play a significant role. Whether it's the nutty undertones from avocado oil or the tang from apple cider vinegar, vegan mayo can be as diverse as the brands or homemade recipes you choose. But this diversity is its strength. With its chameleon-like versatility, it melds beautifully into salads, sandwiches, dips, and more.

4. Brands vs. DIY:

The vegan mayo market has exploded in recent years. Brands like 'Just Mayo' and Hellmann’s Vegan Mayo offer quality, taste, and the convenience of a quick purchase. However, for those who cherish the joy of making food from scratch, or simply want to be in complete control of the ingredients, whipping up your own batch of vegan mayo, like the recipe shared above, is both rewarding and reassuring. You know precisely what's going into your mayo and can adjust ingredients to suit your taste buds perfectly.

Conclusion: vegan mayo vs regular mayo

The age-old debate of vegan mayo vs regular mayo might seem complex, but in reality, it's all about what tickles your taste buds and aligns with your lifestyle choices. If you're someone who hasn't yet dabbled in the world of vegan mayo, I urge you to give it a shot. Perhaps it might surprise you, or maybe you'll find a new favorite. With the plethora of available options, both off the shelves and in your own kitchen, vegan mayo is no longer a distant cousin but a legitimate contender in the condiment arena. So, the next time you're reaching for a jar or blending up a batch, do so with gusto, savoring each creamy, delightful spoonful!

Sharing is caring!