Skip to Content

Can you put Uncrustables in the toaster?

Sharing is caring!

Uncrustables! The delightful sandwich sealer has turned peanut butter and jelly sandwiches into an easy snack that's loved by many. Whether you're a busy parent packing school lunches or someone looking for a quick lunch, Uncrustables have revolutionized the sandwich game. But, ever wonder can you put uncrustables in the toaster?

If you've been debating the best way to enjoy these crustless sandwiches, you've landed at the right place. Let's explore the world of toasting Uncrustables and answer some common questions about these popular snacks.

can you put uncrustables in the toaster

Toasting Uncrustables: The Warm and Crispy Treat

Can you put Uncrustables in the toaster?

The short answer is YES! According to Smucker's, the makers of Uncrustables, using a toaster is a safe and acceptable method of heating up the sandwich. Here's a simple way to do it:

  • Ensure the Uncrustable is completely thawed. A frozen item in a toaster can be a safety hazard.
  • Use medium heat, as high heat can quickly burn the slices of bread.
  • Toast for 15-20 seconds, or until the bread is golden brown, which ensures the best flavor.
  • Be cautious with the gooey filling; it can get quite hot.

Tips to remember when toasting Uncrustables:

  • Always ensure that there are no ice crystals. You wouldn’t want to experience the unpleasant combination of golden brown toast and ice-cold jelly filling.
  • White bread Uncrustables usually toast faster than whole wheat bread ones, so keep an eye out during the toasting process.
  • If you prefer a crispy crust, toaster ovens offer a popular option over traditional toasters.
A pie cut into two uneven halves on a wooden surface, similar to how one might wonder if they can put Uncrustables in the toaster.

Can You Put Uncrustables in the Toaster Oven?

Certainly! A toaster oven is an excellent method for warming up Uncrustables, and it offers more consistent heating compared to a regular pop-up toaster. Using a toaster oven provides the advantage of a crispy exterior while maintaining the gooey interior we all love in an Uncrustable.

To prepare your Uncrustable in a toaster oven:

  1. Thawing: Start by letting the Uncrustable thaw a bit. This step ensures even heating and prevents the center from being too cold while the outside gets crispy.
  2. Setting the Toaster Oven: Preheat your toaster oven to a moderate temperature, around 350°F (175°C).
  3. Baking: Place the Uncrustable on the oven's baking tray and bake for about 8-12 minutes. The exact time might vary depending on your toaster oven's specifics and how crispy you like your sandwich.
  4. Monitor: Keep an eye on it to ensure the sandwich doesn't get too brown or crispy, and always be cautious of the hot filling when you take your first bite.

Using a toaster oven can strike a perfect balance, creating a delightful contrast between the crunchy crust and the warm, smooth filling inside. It's a method that offers both convenience and a delicious outcome!

Can you put Uncrustables in the Air Fryer:

Cooking Uncrustables in an air fryer has grown in popularity due to the enticing crispy finish it delivers. The circulating hot air ensures the exterior of the Uncrustable turns golden brown and slightly crunchy, contrasting beautifully with the soft, gooey filling inside. Typically, thawed Uncrustables are recommended for the air fryer to prevent uneven cooking. Simply place the sandwich in the air fryer basket, set it to a medium heat, and within minutes, you'll have a warm, crispy treat that elevates the simple Uncrustable to a whole new level.

Box of Smucker's Uncrustables peanut butter & grape jelly sandwiches on a countertop, asking if you can put Uncrustables in the toaster.

Can you put Uncrustables in the Microwave:

For those in a rush or seeking a quick snack without the crispiness, the microwave offers a speedy solution to heating Uncrustables. By placing the sandwich on a microwave-safe plate and using a moderate setting, you can have a warm Uncrustable ready to eat in less than a minute. While this method won't provide the crispy exterior that an air fryer does, it ensures a uniformly warm sandwich with a melted, gooey filling. It's essential to be cautious about overheating, as the fillings, especially the jelly, can become scalding hot in a short time.

Can You Put Uncrustables in the Oven?

Yes, Uncrustables can be warmed up in a conventional oven, although it's a less common method than using a toaster or microwave. When using an oven, preheat it to a moderate temperature, around 350°F (175°C). Place the Uncrustables on a baking sheet, ensuring they're completely thawed for even heating. Bake for about 10-15 minutes or until the outside is golden brown and the filling is warm. Using an oven can provide a similar crispy exterior as an air fryer, making the sandwich a delightful balance of warm, gooey insides and a slightly crunchy crust. 

Other ways to enjoy your Uncrustables: 

  1. Straight from the Pack: Uncrustables can be eaten once they’ve thawed without any heating. This method preserves the classic soft texture of the bread and the cool, smooth consistency of the fillings.
  2. Frozen Delight: Especially on hot summer days, a frozen Uncrustable can serve as a cool treat. It's like a PB&J ice cream sandwich!
  3. Dipped in Treats: Dunk your Uncrustable in chocolate or caramel sauce, or roll it in crushed nuts or sprinkles for a dessert twist.
  4. Panini Pressed: For those who want the toasted feel but don’t have a toaster or air fryer, a panini press can be a great alternative. It provides a grilled texture, pressing the sandwich thin and giving a crispy exterior.
  5. Deep-Fried Uncrustable: For a truly indulgent treat, you can deep-fry your Uncrustable! Coat it in a simple batter, and fry until golden. It becomes a rich, crispy outside, gooey inside dessert, perfect with a dusting of powdered sugar.
  6. With Sides: Enhance your Uncrustable experience by pairing it with fresh fruits, a cup of milk, or even a scoop of ice cream.
  7. DIY Toppings: Drizzle some honey, spread a bit of Nutella, or add a dash of cinnamon on top for an extra flavor kick.

Remember, the beauty of Uncrustables lies in their convenience and versatility. Feel free to get creative and customize them to your personal taste preferences!

A pre-packaged peanut butter and grape jelly Uncrustables sandwich with a bite taken out of it, resting on a wooden surface.

Your Uncrustables FAQ: All the Need-to-Knows

1. Are Uncrustables dairy-free?

While most Uncrustables are dairy-free, always check the ingredients list. For example, the main ingredients like peanut butter and jelly typically don’t contain dairy, but other fillings or flavors might.

2. Are Uncrustables vegan?

Some Uncrustables might contain ingredients like honey or dairy derivatives like whey, so not all are vegan. Always refer to the product's ingredients list or Smucker’s website for clarity.

3. How to store Uncrustables?

  • Keep unopened Uncrustables in the freezer section of grocery stores.
  • Uncrustables sandwiches should remain in their plastic wrap until you're ready to eat.
  • Avoid leaving unrefrigerated Uncrustables out for a long time. For safety reasons, if an Uncrustable has been left out at room temperature for more than 6-8 hours, it's best discarded.
  • For a convenient option on-the-go, you can use an ice pack to keep Uncrustables cool and prevent them from thawing too quickly.

4. Are Uncrustables healthy?

Uncrustables, like many pre-made sandwiches, contain high fructose corn syrup, soy lecithin, and other additives. While they make for an easy snack or quick lunch, they might not be the healthiest choice. It's always a good idea to check the nutritional information and decide based on your dietary needs.

5. Uncrustables in an air fryer: Yay or Nay?

Absolutely yay! Heating Uncrustables in an air fryer results in a crispy treat. Just place the thawed Uncrustable sandwich in an air fryer basket and cook at a medium heat setting for a short time. The result? A warm Uncrustable with a crispy crust and gooey peanut butter and jelly filling.

Key Takeaways: Enjoying Uncrustables to the Fullest

  • Toaster Method is King: While there are different ways to heat Uncrustables, the toaster method recommended by Smucker’s brings out the best taste.
  • Be Mindful of Ingredients: While Uncrustables can be a great addition to your diet, it’s important to be aware of ingredients like high fructose corn syrup or non-vegan additives.
  • Air Fryer Uncrustables are Delicious: For those owning an air fryer, it’s a game changer for Uncrustables. The crispy crust combined with the gooey filling makes it a favorite method for many.
  • Storage is Crucial: Properly stored Uncrustables in an airtight container or freezer bag ensures freshness and avoids unpleasant odors or tastes.
  • DIY Uncrustables: Feeling creative? Make your own homemade Uncrustables using slices of bread, your preferred fillings, and stainless steel cookie cutters as a sandwich sealer. It’s an easy air fryer recipe to try the next time you're craving something special.

Conclusion: can you put uncrustables in the toaster?

To wrap it all up, smuckers Uncrustables have paved their way into our hearts and freezers with their convenience and taste. Whether you toast them, air fry them, or enjoy them thawed, they're a delightful treat. So, the next time you find yourself gazing at the freezer aisle, wondering if you should put Uncrustables in the toaster, remember this guide and go for that golden brown deliciousness! Enjoy every bite, and always experiment with creative ways to savor these delightful sandwiches.

Sharing is caring!